Toward Understanding Mystical Consciousness: An Analysis of a Text from Simone Weil

Publication Type

Journal Article

Year of Publication

2003

Author

Evans, Jean
Kourie, Celia E. T.

Journal

Religion &Theology

Volume

10

Number

2

Pages

149-165

Language

English

Keywords

language
mysticism
Searle, John
Katz, Steven

Annotation

A textual analysis of Simone Weil’s mystical experience as described in her letter to Father Perrin dated May 15, 1942. Scholarship on mystical consciousness is examined in relationship to Weil’s experience, particularly the debate between neo-perennialists such as Forman and Stace and constructivists like Steven Katz. Using Katz’s work, an in-depth discussion of the role of language in the construction and understanding of mystical experienced is presented. Five functions language serves in relation to mystical experience are delineated, followed by an examination of these functions in Weil’s text. Drawing on the work of John Searle, the differences between ordinary and extraordinary consciousness are presented and then used to reflect on Weil’s experience.