Indiscretion With Regard to the Unsayable: Weil to the Postmodern

Publication Type

Book Chapter

Year of Publication

2008

Author

Vaughan, William

Book

Detours in Philosophy: Controversies in the Continental Tradtion

Series Volume

4

Pages

59-72

Publisher

Peter Lang

Place Published

New York

Language

English

Series Editor

Rudnick, Hans H

Series Title

Phenomenology & Literature

Keywords

affliction (malheur)
Blanchot, Maurice
language
negative theology
postmodernism

Annotation

Vaughan is looking here at the influence of Weil on the French postmodernist Maurice Blanchot. He states he is not comparing them so much as 'holding them in proximity', arguing both Weil and Blanchot see ties "between an impossible death and an unknowable divine" (p. 61). The roots of such ties, he goes on to state, are to be found in apophatic theology. He then turns to Weil's writing on affliction saying it is here she most reflects the 'via negativa'. He briefly presents Weil's thought on affliction but then turns to focus at greater length on Blanchot's response to and use of this thought in his work. The focus throughout the chapter is on language and its inadequacy. He ends the chapter with a critical reflection on Weil's work in the face of the postmodern discussion of language.